In economics, knightian uncertainty is risk that is immeasurable, impossible to calculate. Knightian uncertainty that predict joint movements in perceived knightian uncertainty and measured risk premia, such as those present in credit spreads. The concept acknowledges some fundamental degree of ignorance, a limit to knowledge, and an essential unpredictability of future events. I incorporate a managers ambiguity aversion into a static tradeo model. Asymmetric information and security design under knightian.
Finally, we give conditions under which some assets are not traded due to uncertainty aversion. In this sense, the existence of knightian uncertainty is not just a quasiphilosophical dispute. Using a di erenceindi erence methodology, i nd that when uncertainty is resolved, a me dian rm in the u. If knightian uncertainty is recognized in these models, a reference measure need not exist, see, e.
Risk is objective, testable, consistent with standard empirical methodologies e. Monetary policymaking in the presence of knightian. A few corrections of obvious typos were made for this website edition. In technical parlance, this is knightian uncertainty, named for frank knight, an economist who wrote a 1921 book. Risk, uncertainty, and pro t risk \roulette objective probabilities uncertainty \horse races no probabilities many entrepreneurial decisions are \horseraces startup nancial markets. In particular, knight used the word risk to describe the measurable uncertainty, where the possible outcomes are known and they can be classi. This paper models how knightian uncertainty over risk exposures to the collapsed assets a. Infogap models of uncertainty provide a nonprobabilistic quanti. The risk is defined as the situation of winning or losing something worthy.
Risk and uncertainty as reflected in required capital calculations address only adverse consequences, while provision for uncertainty in the valuation of liabilities or in. Policy uncertainty corrupts the formulaic risk modeling engaged in by economists and quants. Labor supply, selfinsurance and knightian uncertainty. September 3, 2009 abstract the collapse of the housing price bubble during 2007 and 2008 was accompanied by high interbank lending spreads, and a partial collapse in interbank lending. Viability and arbitrage under knightian uncertainty. To address this puzzle, i examine the e ect of knightian uncertainty on leverage.
As knight saw it, an everchanging world brings new opportunities for. Risk can be measured and quantified, through theoretical models. In each period, an unemployed worker draws a wage offer, from a wage distribution 5 f0. A critical assessment with jonathan weinstein a bayesian approach to precautionary policies uncertainty and disagreement in equilibrium models with eran shmaya.
Difference between risk and uncertainty with comparison. For instance, within complete production economies we find that knightian uncertainty can generate an endogenous stock market participation, a feature that cannot be obtained by the other robustness definitions. Knight wrote that risk is randomness in which events have measurable probabilities. Politics, at its core, is a dense and sticky web of relationships. Uncertainty is a condition where there is no knowledge about the future events. Labor supply, selfinsurance and knightian uncertainty hening liu northern illinois university abstract the focus of this paper is on the implications of income uncertainty for the optimal labor supply. Risk is ergodic probabilities, knightian uncertainty is mixtures of ergodic measures. The meaningful distinction between knightian uncertainty, which is often attributed to frank knight 1921, and risk is allowed. As jochen runde quips it is safe to say that frank knight is more widely quoted than read on his eponymous distinction between risk and uncertainty runde 1998, p. Henceforth i use the term uncertainty or ambiguity in the sense of knight 1921, who first defined risk and uncertainty independently.
Iptsjrcec oecd conference on eied december 9, 2014 1 1. Frank knight was an idiosyncratic economist who formalized a distinction between risk and uncertainty in his 1921 book, risk, uncertainty, and profit. Knightian uncertainty and interbank lending matthew pritsker. Knightian uncertainty is often referred to as uncertainty about the extent to which the expected mean a key parameter of the probability distribution is incorrect. Even though, in its purest form, a predictable future would render humans mere automatons unwinding in a clockwork universe, humans find the uncertainty posed by the unknowability of the future so unnerving that we go to great lengths to avoid it. Knightian uncertainty, general equilibrium theory, financial markets, determi. In chapter three, i consider a firms decision to exercise real options, when the firm faces knightian uncertainty about the evolution of project value. The text has been altered as little as possible from the original edition risk, uncertainty, and profit, frank h. A note on consumption and savings under knightian uncertainty. Uncertainty, however, describes events with unknown or objectively unmeasurable probabilities.
Insert table 1 about here the key difference between knightian uncertainty and the other two types is that knightian uncertainty involves dealing with a future that has no discernible distribution whatsoever, not even in theory. Knightian uncertainty critique of the probabilistic model frank knight. Full facsimile of the original edition, not reproduced with optical recognition software. In carroll 2015 and antic 2015, the principal does not know what actions are available to the agent and demands robustness. For example, unlike the standard risk neutral model, it is no longer possible for the. I provide two continuous time applications extended from the discrete time applications in miao and wang 2011 that show the value of waiting which increases with risk decreases with. The difference between risk and uncertainty can be drawn clearly on the following grounds. Knight put forward his ideas on uncertainty in his doctoral thesis and then turned it into his classic book risk, uncertainty and profit 1921. The uncertainty that the worker faces is much broader and deeper, and thus, our assumption of no learning taking place is a reasonable one for knightian uncertainty. In economics, knightian uncertainty is a lack of any quantifiable knowledge about some possible occurrence, as opposed to the presence of quantifiable risk e. We show that optimal contracts with knightian uncertainty can differ from those without.
For this reason, the crisis has cast new attention on an idea about risk from decades past. Risk, robustness and knightian uncertainty in continuous. Knightian uncertainty is named after university of chicago economist frank knight. Alnajjar and jonathan weinstein dtea, paris may 20 presentation also draws from ideas in. Moreover, under knightian uncertainty the structure of an equilibrium depends strongly on the completeness of the underlying economy. Knightian uncertainty and risk article pdf available in journal of strategy and management 74. An infogap perspective decision making in times of.
844 1243 343 777 1258 865 984 827 403 145 459 1251 681 918 1064 1361 1323 945 495 860 41 1464 88 761 489 785 649 911 1396 1425 1188 982 727 410 1217 165